Book Review

The Always Prayer Shawl

Sheldon Oberman, Ted Lewin, Illus.; $19.99 cloth 1-878093-22-3, 32 pp., 8 3/4 X 11 1/4

Boyds Mills/McClelland & Stewart, Dec.1993 (ages 7+)

Quill and Quire January 1994

Review by Annette Goldsmith

From the rather sombre cover showing a contemplative boy wearing a prayer shawl, it is clear that this is a picture book for older readers In simple, direct sentences, Winnipeg author, songwriter, and teacher Sheldon Oberman recounts how young Adam and his parents flee the terror of Czarist Russia. Adam's beloved grandfather stays behind, giving Adam his prayer shawl and some advice - "Some things change. And some things don't." - as parting gifts. The rest of the book demonstrates that one can retain one's identity in a new country, amid constant change, by keeping faith with tradition. The story ends as Adam, now a grandfather, passes on the same advice to his grandson.

This collaboration between author and artist is a happy one: distinguished American illustrator Ted Lewin's paintings lend depth and dignity to Oberman's story. In the first half, the illustrations are realistic black-and-white water-colours. They switch to colour when Adam grows up. The transition is disconcerting, since it happens on the second page of a double-page spread, but that is not a bad thing in itself. The book is beautifully designed, with spacious double-page spreads, elegant typography, and apropos end papers. The design lends Adam's black-and-white family photos an immediacy that is in keeping with the book's theme.

Students in grades 3 or 4 and older will appreciate reading this versatile book. Pair it with Russell Freedman's Immigrant Kids fascinating look at European immigrant children in America, or with the charming Something from Nothing, Phoebe Gilman's Jewish folktale about a prized piece of clothing cut down until nothing is left but a story. Jewish readers will recognize the particulars of The Always Prayer Shawl but the experiences it describes are universal


Go to top
Return to first page